You watched the next episode without me.

Casey v. Morgan/Relationships/Filed Sep 25, 2026

Two episodes of a shared show were watched while one partner was away.

Plaintiff

Casey

We agreed this was our show and would only watch it together. My partner watched two episodes while I was away and then pretended not to know what happened.

Defense

Morgan

We had not watched it together in almost three weeks, and I wanted to finish the season. I offered to rewatch the episodes.

Findings of the court

A shared-show pact existed, then sat for three weeks. Two episodes and a rewatch offer do not justify a penalty.

They had agreed to watch the show together.
Almost three weeks passed without an episode.
Morgan offered to rewatch the two episodes.

The court has reached a decision.

Verdict

Rewatch the two episodes and move on.

The pact was real, and so was the three-week gap. Pretending not to know the plot was petty. The remedy is the rewatch Morgan already offered, not a formal loss.

Order

Morgan rewatches those two episodes with Casey. No further penalty.

A three-week pause is a long time to hold a show hostage.

Community vote

Did the Court get it right?

The ruling above is the Court’s. This is only what the community thinks of it.

Be the first to weigh in.

0 votes

Community Appeal

A free review is earned, not assumed.

A public ruling earns a free Appeals Court review when 25 members vote and 70% say the Court got it wrong.